Wagner Subaru
Subscribe Anywhere
Subscribe Anywhere
Subscribe Anywhere
Wagner Subaru
Nov
20
2026
From the Print

Spring(s) | Laughing on the edge

Right off, I should probably say I’m not really a fan kind of person. Proximity to a famous person doesn’t produce in me an almost speechless awe and excitement, nor a manic desire for a selfie, an autograph or whatever else might seem to extend that nearness into my everyday life, as it may for some.

Perhaps that might have something to do with the fact that as a tenured professor at a research-1 university, I’ve had to spend most of my time either fighting to win that tenure or fighting to maintain it, which often means being buried in one, the other or both of academic libraries or obscure archives — in other words, being the proverbial person with their nose in a book — and all of that pretty far away from the constant buzz of popular culture, in which many famous people are often found. As an example of what I mean, let me add this: Some time ago, I spent three months plowing every day through the papers of l’Abbé Grégoire at the Bibliothèque de l’Arsenal in Paris, reading pamphlets and manuscripts detailing the French and Haitian Revolutions in 18th-century French — and not hanging around under the Eiffel Tower or somewhere along the Seine. I mean, really, who does that?

On the ground, though, it also means I watch very little TV and see only the occasional film, and one or the other only very selectively, while most of the time also steering pretty clear of social media, at least for now. Taken together, I’m sure all of that probably makes me more of an analyst of popular culture, if I express any opinions on that front, than I am a participant in or consumer of it.

So if in this frame I say that I’m not a fan of Dave Chappelle, you’ll know that I don’t at all mean it in the same sense as what you get when you open your computer, and the Bing homepage asks you to choose whether you like the image it presents or whether you’re not a fan and therefore don’t like it. Not being a fan kind of person at all just puts me completely outside of that loop. Now that we’ve established that, maybe I should tell you why I brought all of this up, anyway, as it really isn’t as out of the blue as it may seem.

This was actually a preamble to what I want to say about Dave Chappelle’s elusive film “Dave Chappelle: Live in Real Life,” which I took the rare opportunity to see when I was in Yellow Springs at the end of August, and it was showing at the Little Art downtown. But, as I soon discovered, this is easier said than done, as any public engagement with that film also immediately demands engaging with the fallout around the issue of transphobia in Mr. Chappelle’s special “The Closer,” which I have also now seen — the first Dave Chappelle special I have ever seen, for the above reasons — which was aired not long after “Dave Chappelle: Live in Real Life” was shown at the Tribeca Film Festival in New York City in 2021. And from here, things suddenly become a whole lot more complex.

Even though now in 2026 that controversy is not as bitter as it was in 2021, its damaging impact remains — it is a large part of the reason why “Dave Chappelle: Live in Real Life” remains elusive for the would-be viewer.

To clear the air a bit, then, let me say here that in the end, if I am a fan of anything, I’m certainly a fan of Yellow Springs. And though generally not a fan kind of person, I am nevertheless especially a fan of Yellow Springs from a particular and relevant point of view: that of having been a Black person whose formative years were all spent here, in the progressive, racially accepting atmosphere that was the village of the late ’60s, and then the ’70s and ’80s. I always say that having grown up as a Black person in Yellow Springs at that time forever unfits one to be a Black person in this country, as here there was no enforced drinking the poison cup of understanding yourself as a second-class citizen — as less human than anyone else.

Living as I do now outside the village, the raw truth of that reality, of not having drained that cup, invariably and undeniably shows up like a fresh wound in many mainstream encounters, never failing to surprise external assumptions and/or expectations into uncomfortable, unreceptive silence.

Along these lines, I should note that this is meant to be neither a defense, nor a critique, nor a review, but another thing entirely. This is not an angle into “The Closer” controversy that was explored by the mainstream media because — and let’s be honest here — how could it be? Could the mainstream media know what it is to live and breathe, not just talking about beloved community, but actually living it, every single day, through shared history and legacy in an extraordinarily tight-knit community whose common values hold that way of life transcendent?

What the mainstream media did not pick up on, perhaps couldn’t pick up on, was precisely this, and what it might mean for Mr. Chappelle’s comedy. Mr. Chappelle’s youth was shaped by what it is to grow up Black in Yellow Springs, as well as by the time he spent in Washington, D.C. But for Mr. Chappelle, all of this goes still further than that, as he was also influenced by his father, William David Chappelle III, the Antioch professor who co-founded H.U.M.A.N., or Help Us Make a Nation, an activist, community-building, grassroots organization that sought to radically dismantle systemic and institutionalized racism in America — something Mr. Chappelle also briefly mentions in the film.

Viewed in tandem, then, it can perhaps be reasonably assumed that for Mr. Chappelle there is likely both a rich heritage and a responsibility to uphold, each of which lies behind his rhetoric — yet it’s hard, if not impossible, to see behind that curtain if you don’t have the tools to do so. Acknowledging that the significance of these two things might require something different, a stronger, more unusual level of risk, something that could, perhaps, be considered a kind of laughing on the edge, perhaps so far along that edge that it even becomes somewhat unfamiliar comedy territory, might be one place to start.

And rewatching “The Closer” with that in mind might lift that curtain, perhaps just a little, perhaps just enough to see the horizon of something new. The reward, then, could be being able to come to “Dave Chappelle: Live in Real Life” not with expectation, but with something more like real understanding.

*Cyraina Johnson-Roullier is associate professor of modern literature and literature of the Americas at the University of Notre Dame, a co-curatorial member of the Racial Imaginary Institute and a former Ford Foundation postdoctoral fellow.

Topics: ,

No comments yet for this article.

The Yellow Springs News encourages respectful discussion of this article.
You must to post a comment.

Don't have a login? Register for a free YSNews.com account.

WP2Social Auto Publish Powered By : XYZScripts.com
The Yellow Springs News